Untangling Tricky Theology: Heaven and Hell

Untangling Tricky Theology: Heaven and Hell

Revelation 21:1-6
Then I saw a new heaven and a new earth, for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and the sea was no more. And I saw the holy city, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. And I heard a loud voice from the throne saying,
“See, the home of God is among mortals.
He will dwell with them;
they will be his peoples,
and God himself will be with them and be their God;
he will wipe every tear from their eyes.
Death will be no more;
mourning and crying and pain will be no more,
for the first things have passed away.”
And the one who was seated on the throne said, “See, I am making all things new.” Also he said, “Write this, for these words are trustworthy and true.” Then he said to me, “It is done! I am the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End. To the thirsty I will give water as a gift from the spring of the water of life.

My neighborhood goes bananas for Halloween. I don’t think a grim reaper in the yard is a statement about the afterlife, but I think it is one way we try to tame death. We hang orange lights over dark subjects. We put a skeleton in the yard holding a cocktail and say cheers to some of our deepest fears.

But I’ll tell you what people say when they pull me aside in the hallway. Nobody asks about skeletons. They do ask, Pastor Becca, you got a minute? I wonder if I will see my mom again. What was my grandfather looking at, at the end, when he talked to his late sister? Do I have to believe in eternal punishment to be a Christian? And how do I watch the news and not think this world is already hell? Most questions are not academic or even theological. They are about a person.

I don’t think we need to know the blueprint of heaven or the temperature of hell to know that there is more, much more to our existence than our first breath and our last, and more to our destiny than the up elevator or the down one. Another thing I know: if we get quiet enough, we hear it. When we love hard, when we grieve deeply, when we sing and mean it, and sometimes
when we look close into the eyes of a baby, or a dying person, or a suffering person, it rushes through us, that “more” that we yearn for.

But there is also a lot that scares us, like scorching billboards on the side of the highway or our own brains that say around 1 am, “You know what we haven’t thought about lately? Hell.”
Gee thanks.

So I’ll start with some teaching, hang some lights from our tradition around the big words Heaven and Hell with a big asterisk next to them, glowing like a pumpkin, to honor what is hidden from our eyes on purpose.

In the Bible, there are several words and images for heaven. There is shamayim in Hebrew and ouranos in Greek, words that can mean the sky above us or the dwelling place of God. There is paradise, a word for a garden. There is the Father’s house with its many dwelling places. There is a feast, a city, a new heaven and a new earth, like today’s text from Revelation.

And there are several words that English Bibles have translated as hell. There is Sheol, the Hebrew realm of the dead. There is Gehenna, named for the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem, a place associated with child sacrifice and the worst things people do to each other that was almost always on fire and became an image of judgment. Scripture gives us a whole
collection of images, and we should be careful about pressing them into one tidy map of the afterlife. But when Jesus speaks to the dying man beside him, his promise is wonderfully personal: “Today you will be with me in paradise.” With me. It is about a person.

Much of what fuels our imagination does not come from the Bible. The nine circles of hell come from Dante’s Inferno. “Better to reign in hell than serve in heaven” comes from Milton’s Paradise Lost. Some early church fathers wrote vividly about eternal torment, while others, like Clement of Alexandria and Gregory of Nyssa, hoped for a judgment that heals and restores. Meanwhile the church was crafting the Apostles’ Creed, which says Jesus descended to
the dead, or in some versions, into hell: the assurance that death itself was defeated on the cross. Jonathan Edwards filled our country’s childhood with images of damnation in “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.” Nowhere does Scripture describe a devil in red tights carrying a pitchfork. We have inherited a vivid collection of poetry, paintings, and Halloween decorations,
and sometimes it is hard to remember which parts we learned in Sunday school and which parts we picked up in the costume aisle. So we need to ask: What does Scripture actually say? And what does it reveal about the God we meet in Jesus Christ?

Jesus talks about Heaven more than anyone else in Scripture, especially in Matthew. Usually he describes it not like individual souls floating up but a jaw-dropping reality coming down, the Kingdom of Heaven, breaking in, breaking through, making all things new, when the poor are fed, when prisoners are visited, when outcasts are welcomed. A new heaven, and a new earth, breaking in, now and in the age to come. It’s about the least and the last and the lost and the littlest person cared for.

In seminary, I was taught that Hell is separation from God, as an experience of
abandonment, as the lie we are on our own, that no one is coming, that nothing really matters. Hell is like the grip of addiction, the eyes of a person drawn like a moth to a false light that consumes their life as it feeds their fear that says “No one loves you.” Hell is children picking through rubble and refugees being wrestled to the ground and soldiers who can’t sleep due to the
flashbacks and the long shadow of depression that keeps someone in bed for months or worse, and injustice running amok, all because of the great lie: “No one loves you. This is all there is Forever.”

But we know that’s not true. In fact, Jesus gave us this great commission, in Matthew 28, to go and tell good news that there is more, much more, than the worst thing that has happened to us or the worst thing we have done. There is someone who comes looking for us. Someone who has entered the depths of human suffering and Godforsakenness and carried love all the way down. When Jesus says, “You will be with me” to a dying thief on the cross next to him, that promise reaches into every place where we are certain we have been forgotten. With me. Even here. Even you. Turns out it is about a person.

Listen again to what John sees. Not people climbing a ladder out of this world, but God coming down into it. “See, the home of God is among mortals.” He will dwell with them. He will wipe every tear from their eyes. The hand of God coming close to wet cheeks. Death will be no more. Such a personal image of this eternal more.

Most of my peers, and maybe yours too, don’t think about “more” very often. They prefer a generous agnosticism to the brutal certainty that sounds like “only us!” from many religious people. But almost always, I find an openness to something more.

So here is what I say, and I say it as a confession, not a conclusion. There is a lot I don’t know. But I believe we will be with God, and I believe God is very good. I believe in Jesus, who told us not to be afraid, and who said heaven is like a mustard seed and a banquet and treasure and yeast, radical generosity bubbling up all around us and waiting for us and inviting us to take
part.

And to the question in the hallway, Do I have to believe in eternal punishment to be a Christian? Faithful Christians have answered that differently for two thousand years, and the creeds do not require us to carry a particular map of the afterlife. But they always point to a person, the one who says, “You will be with me.”

There’s a parable I love, written by Wayne Dyer. In a mother’s womb were two babies. One asked the other, “Do you believe in life after delivery?”

“Of course,” said the second. “There has to be something after delivery. Maybe there will be more light than here. Maybe we’ll walk with our legs and eat with our mouths.”

“Nonsense,” said the first. “Walking is impossible. Eating with our mouths? Ridiculous! The umbilical cord gives us everything we need. And if there were life after delivery, why has no one ever come back? Delivery is the end. There is nothing but darkness and silence.”

“I don’t know what it will be like,” said the second. “But I think we will meet Mother, and she will take care of us.”

“Mother? You believe in Mother? If she exists, where is she now?”

“She is all around us. We are of her. In her we live and move and have our being. And sometimes, if you are very quiet, you can hear her. You can hear her loving voice, calling down from above.”

Let me close with my friend Suz. Her mother was near the end of her life, and death was close, the way you can feel it in a room. And her mother seemed to be seeing someone. Her eyes weren’t on the ceiling or on the people around her bed. She was listening, or looking, at someone nobody else could see. Suz and her mom did what Christians often do. They prayed the prayer Jesus taught us. Thy kingdom come. Thy will be done. And Suz told me that she leaned in and asked, “Mom, is it coming? Can you see it?” and her mom’s lips seemed to stretch into one last smile.

I am the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End. To the thirsty I will give water as a gift from the spring of the water of life.

That is all we need to know. Let’s go out there and give ‘em heaven.

Amen.